Lemonade from Lemons

by | Jul 11, 2011 | Equipment, Tanks | 5 comments

Last summer about this time marks the demise of my oldest reef system. A faulty heater that stuck in the on position while I was away for the weekend turned my nearly 15-year labor of love into a frothy cauldron of putrid decay. The acrid smell of Lodo, as Rich Ross so eloquently put it, permeated my office so thoroughly we were forced to close for a few days as I cleared out the ghastly remains. It was a total loss. Gone were 15-year-old coral colonies and fish nearly the same age—the only survivor an ORA clownfish that somehow, inexplicably, was able to hang in and bear witness to the horror.

It was rough going for a few weeks. I have many other reef systems so it is not that I had lost my passion entirely, but still, old friends were missed and the fragile nature of our undertaking was stripped bare. Lots to think about, lots of decisions to be made, lots of options. I’ve always believed that with setbacks come opportunities, and I was determined to make lemonade out of lemons.

I decided to rip out the old system completely.  The tank was, after all, nearly 16 years old with the requisite scratches and rusty iron stand as proof.  Shortly after removal, one of those aforementioned opportunities presented itself in the form of a rather generous donation of a complete, custom built 220g. 3/4″ glass behemoth with cabinet and canopy and all the equipment and trimmings.  Talk about serious upgrade.  Talk about options and opportunities.  I was staring at an aquatic tabula rasa.  I could make this system into anything I wanted.  There were no animals that needed immediate housing, no time pressures, no aquascaping “blind” because of there wasn’t time to let the water clear with fish and corals in buckets waiting.

I had no strong feelings about what I wanted to do with this new system, but I did know I didn’t want another full blown reef despite the temptation of a gazillion new corals and actual places to put them.  My aquariums are on public display and I felt like showing a different face of the hobby while presenting myself with new challenges.  Because I had jumped almost immediately into the reefy end of things, and all my upgrades and expansions over the years involved bigger or better reefing, I never really had the chance to keep a huge range of amazing fish because the invertebrates were always primary.

So begins the new adventure, a FOWLR system — ok, ok I’ve already mentally committed to corallimorphs and other hardy, plentiful and stress-free inverts —-where the rockwork is the main design element and fish reign supreme. Which fish?  Well, that is a very good question.  A question I’ll tackle another time.

  • Randy Donowitz

    Randy Donowitz has been keeping aquariums most of his life. During the mid 1980s and 90s he was consumed with the breeding of African Cichlids. In 1994 he purchased his first marine system- a simple 55 gallon reef setup and he has been an incurable coralholic ever since. Randy's articles have appeared in numerous hobbyist publications including Aquarium Frontiers, Advanced Aquarist, Marine Fish and Reef USA Annual and Aquarium Fish magazine. Currently, he curates and maintains the 3 system, 700 gallon coral reef display at Pratt Institute in Brooklyn, NY where he enjoys the privilege of sharing his knowledge and love of the hobby with students, staff, and community members from around the Tri-State area.

    View all posts


  1. lfsmarineguy

    It doesn’t happen that often but whenever I’ve lost a tank there is about a 24hr period where I’m inconsolable until the tank is cleaned out entirely. That’s followed by a week or so of stacks of paper and computer files full of ideas for the new setup. You can’t plan for catastrophic equipment failure… but you can plan a new tank!!!!! lol

  2. Rich Ross

    I vote for a lemon tank.

  3. Tony Vargas

    It looks great, and I know with you behind the wheel that tank is going to look friggin’ awesome down the road. Suggestion, get yourself an Apex controller, it has saved my tank’s life several times over. It’s worth every dime.

  4. VitalApparatuz

    Great decision.I did the same thing on my living room with our 2nd tank . All the bizzaro fish I never could keep on the reef 🙂

  5. Michael Rice

    What a tease! I’ll be following along as you, hopefully, keep us updated.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Events