Spectral Analysis Of Recent Metal Halide Lamps And Ballast Combinations

During the last year or so several new metal halide lamps have made it into the market, along with some new ballasts recommended for the lamps. This article is a continuation of the series [references 1-5], and the sixth in the series. Included in this article are results from our testing of several of the new lamps and ballasts. Table 1 shows the list of lamp and ballast combinations tested for this article.

Table 1: List of Lamp and ballasts tested for this article
LampBallast
400W Ushio 10000KMagnetek Ballast
PFO – “HQI”
Venture Pulse Start
“HQI”-Taiwan
400W Ushio BlueMagnetek Ballast
PFO – “HQI”
Venture Pulse Start
“HQI” – Taiwan
400W AB 10000KMagnetek Ballast
PFO – “HQI”
Venture Pulse Start
“HQI” – Taiwan
Sylvania Aqua Arc 400WMagnetek Ballast
PFO – “HQI”
Venture Pulse Start
“HQI”- Taiwan
Vion Z6 – 400WMagnetic Ballast
Venture Pulse Start
Xanium 400WMagnetic Ballast
Venture Pulse Start
Vion Z6 – 250WMagnetic Ballast
Electronic Ballast
Vion Z6 – 175WMagnetic Ballast
AB 175W 10000KMagnetic Ballast
Venture Pulse Start

The magnetic ballasts used are the Magnetek F-can ballasts(ANSI-M57, M58, M59) and the Pulse start ballasts used are the Venture Pulse Start Ballasts(ANSI M135, M136, M138). Although, there are special Pulse Start metal halide lamps designed for these ballasts – these ballasts can also be used for standard metal halide lamps (although the benefits of the pulse start lamp will be lost.) [http://www.venturelighting.com/TechCenter/Faqs/tech_center_faq.htm ]. Benefits of pulse start lamps are claimed to include improved light output, lower operating costs, better lumen maintenance for consistent light levels, improved color stability, faster warm-up and re-strike, colder starting and more. Whether these same benefits can be obtained on the aquarium lamps remains to be seen.

The two “HQI” ballasts used were the PFO Lighting and a Taiwanese ballast (sold by All Seas). The term “HQI” has become a source of confusion – it is being used by the aquarium lighting companies to specify ballasts for the European (primarily German made lamps), the single ended 400W and double ended 250W and 150W lamps. HQI is a registered trademark of OSRAM GmbH. In some cases, the “HQI” ballasts sold within the aquarium hobby are standard ANSI ballasts recommended for the lamps by the manufacturers (e.g. ANSI-M80 and M81 ballasts for the doubled ended 150W and 250W double ended lamps). In other cases they are ballasts not specifically designed for these lamps, but sold as “HQI” because they are claimed to match the operating specifics of the European lamps. This confusion is brought on in large part by the fact that the lamps are being made in Europe under European specs and there may not be a direct match with the ANSI ballast specifications. There is considerable trial and error required to find ballasts for these lamps, and the issue of whether these ballasts are in fact suitable for the lamps is open to debate.

For each lamp/ballast combination listed, data was collected on the Spectrum, Photosynthetic Photon flux Density (PPFD) or PAR, as well as data on the power consumption of the ballasts. The power consumption was determined using a Vector True RMS power meter into which the ballast was plugged. The Vector power meter also records the voltage and current. The test setup used was the same as previous lamp tests [1].

Advertisement


 

Ushio 400w 10000k

The Ushio lamps are a very popular lamp in the hobby, and this lamp was te sted to establish a baseline for comparison. Also, there have been recent claims that this lamp burns brighter with “HQI” ballasts, and similar claims for the Venture Pulse Start ballast.

ushio10k.gif

The spectral plot of the USHIO 400W 10000K running on these different ballasts.

Table 2: Ushio 400W lamp with Different Ballasts
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)428118.13.94123.77650
Pulse Start412117.94.03117.37507
PFO-HQI512119.25.471658071
HQI-Taiwan482119.34.28167.18110

 

 

As seen from the plot, there is very minimal change in output of the lamp when using the Venture Pulse Start ballast or the M59 ballast. However when using the lamp with the PFO-HQI ballast and the HQI-Taiwan ballast, the output is about 36.5% higher, but it is also accompanied by an increase in power consumption. The amperage draw is about 35% higher with the PFO-HQI ballast, but not as high with the HQI-Taiwan. It could be that these “HQI” ballasts are overdriving the lamp, given that the spec sheet at (www.ushio.com) states that the recommended ballast is M59. The long term implications of lamp performance using “HQI” ballasts have not been tested.

 

Ushio 400w Blueushio-blue.gif

Table 3: Ushio 400W Blue lamp with different ballasts
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)451118.34.13109.9Out of range
Pulse Start445118.54.20102Out of range
PFO-HQI486119.55.75112.0Out of range
HQI-Taiwan450120.14.05106.5Out of range

 

Advertisement


As seen from the data, there is very little variation in the output irrespective of the ballast used; however, the PFO-HQI ballast draws more current and about 10% more power. This lamp is very similar in spectral characteristics when compared to the Radium 400W 20000K lamp (see reference [1] for a spectral plot of the Radium lamp).

 

Sylvania Aqua Arc 400W

These lamps were listed on Hellolights.com and it was the first sylvaniaaqua.giftime we had heard of them. Table 4 shows the test data on this lamp as run on the 4 different ballasts.

Table 4: Sylvania Aqua Arc 400W lamp with different ballasts
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)438117.83.8114610454
Pulse Start447118.44.1113210409
PFO-HQI467119.95.5613310335
PFO-Taiwan480119.34.3216210014

As seen from these plots, there is very little difference in the performance of the three ballasts – M59, Pulse Start, and PFO-HQI. The HQI-Taiwan ballast generated slightly more PAR, with most of the increase in the non-blue wavelengths, at the expense of higher power consumption. Overall, this seems like an excellent lamp. Major difference from the Ushio 10000K is the difference in the peaks – at 420 and 436 nm.

 

Aqualine 400 W 10000 Kab-1.gif

Table 5: Aqualine Bushke 400W 10000K Lamps with different Ballasts
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)418118.23.8794.76616
Pulse Start415118.23.971016995
PFO-HQI485119.05.561339104
HQI-Taiwan464119.04.201409481

Again, here it is quite obvious that there are two very similar groups of spectral output, with the M59 and Pulse Start Ballast having almost identical output, and the two “HQI” ballasts generating higher output with almost similar spectrums.

 

400W Vion Z6 and Xanium (Hellolights.com)

Recently Hellolights.com introduced the Vion Z6 and Xanium Series of lamps at attractive prices; this has piqued the interests of many hobbyists.

Advertisement


vion10k.gif

This figure shows the spectral output of the Vion Z6 400W lamps.

Table 6: Vion Z6 400W
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)436119.33.9366.926348
Pulse Start418118.54.1169.46359

 

 

 

As you will see from the spectral plots, the Vion Z6 sold as a 10000K lamp appears as a poor imitation of the Ushio 10000K, with a lot less PAR and much lower color temperature. The output for the Vion Z6 is very similar for both the ballasts.

Xanium 400Wxanium15k.gif

Table 7: Xanium 400W
BallastPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Standard (M59)467119.44.22100.1Out of range
Pulse Start428119.03.8294.4

 

 

This is an interesting lamp. Although it has a large spike in the 454 nm range like some of the other similar lamps (ALS and Blueline, see tests results in reference [5]) it has a better PPFD value when compared to these lamps. The PPFD values for the ALS and Blueline lamps were 66.84 and 71.60 respectively. This lamp is currently being marketed as a 15000K lamp, and like all the other lamps with predominantly blue color its CCT could not be calculated by the software.

Advertisement


 

175W AB 10000K Lamps

Two new 175W Aqualine lamps were also tested in an identical manner with the standard (M57) Magnetek Ballast and the venture Pulse Start ballast.

Table 8: 175W Standard Ballasts
LampPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Lamp1215119.31.9553.79269
Lamp 2213120.31.9264.411687
Table 9: 175W Venture Pulse Start Ballast
LampPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Lamp1213120.22.0351.89269
Lamp 2208119.92.0460.712193

In addition, we tested two used 175W AB 10000K lamps that were used for 3200 hours over a period of eleven months. These lamps were driven by a pulse start ballast throughout their use. The owner indicated that he was very surprised that the inner arc tube had not blackened, and hence was very curious to know if the lamps were still useful. The data for these lamps is as follows:

ab175nu.gif

The plot showing spectral results for one of the lamps is shown.

Table 10: AB 175W Used Lamps (3200 hrs) Venture Pulse Start Ballast
LampPowerInput VoltsInput AmpPPFDCCT
Lamp1212119.42.0450.88442
Lamp 2206119.42.0057.310011

 

 

 

Although the data is not statistically analyzable, a few points of observation can be made. The variation among the 2 new lamps was almost 20%, and variation between the used lamps was about 15%. The pulse start ballasts do not significantly impact the output of the lamps. But, the used lamps had PPFD values within the range of the new lamps tested. This could potentially imply that the Pulse Start Ballast is less severe on the lamp and has increased the lamp life. This would be very significant for the reef aquarist since it would increase the length of time the lamps could be used, and merits further study.

 

Conclusion

As new lamps and ballasts are being brought into the hobby, it has become increasingly difficult for hobbyists to keep up and know enough about these lamps and ballasts to make an educated choice. It is our hope that this series of articles will provide the hobbyists information to help them make an informed choice. The introduction of pulse start ballasts is intriguing especially if it helps in increasing the life of the lamps. Further long term studies would be needed to establish this. The effect of the “HQI” ballasts used on some lamps appears to be a higher output. They also run the lamps with more energy and their impact on lamp life is an open issue that will require further study.

 

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank several people whose help made this study possible. They were kind enough to provide us with lamps and ballasts for testing: Dave and Patrick at PFO Lighting, Brain at HelloLights.com, Brad at Aqua-Medic, Leonhard Ho and Roger Huff. Finally, we would like to thank Dr. Paul Walker of Penn State University for the use of the spectroradiometer and a dark room for testing the lamps.

 

References

  1. Joshi, S. 1998. Spectral Analysis of Metal Halide Lamps Used in the Reef Aquarium Hobby Part 1: New 400-watt Lamps, http://www.animalnetwork.com/fish2/aqfm/1998/nov/features/1/default.asp
  2. Joshi, S. and Morgan D. 1999. Spectral Analysis of Metal Halide Lamps Used in the Reef Aquarium Hobby Part II: Used 400-watt Lamps http://www.animalnetwork.com/fish2/aqfm/1999/jan/features/2/default.asp
  3. Joshi, S. and Morgan, D. 1999. Spectral Analysis of Metal Halide Lamps Used in the Reef Aquarium Hobby Part III: New and used 250-watt Lamps http://www.animalnetwork.com/fish2/aqfm/1999/dec/features/2/default.asp
  4. Joshi, S. and Morgan D., “Spectral Analysis of Metal Halide Lamps – Do Ballasts Make a Difference,” 2001 Annual Marine Fish and Reef USA, Fancy Publications.
  5. Joshi, S., “Spectral Analysis of Recent Metal Halide Lamps: Part IV– 10000K and 12000K lamps,” 2002 Annual Marine Fish and Reef USA, Fancy Publications.
Categories:
  Advanced Aquarist, Advanced Aquarist
Sanjay Joshi
About

 Sanjay Joshi

  (51 articles)

Sanjay Joshi in real life is a Professor of Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering at Penn State University. He has been a reef addict since 1992, and currently keeps several reef aquariums at home including a 500G SPS coral dominated reef. He also co-manages the 500G aquarium at Penn State. He has published several articles in magazines such as Marine Fish and Reef Annual, Aquarium Frontiers, Aquarium Fish, and Advanced Aquarist. In addition, he has been an invited speaker at several marine aquarium society meetings in the US and Europe. He received the MASNA award in 2006, for his contributions to the marine aquarium hobby.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.