nycfishy

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Queens NY
Just got red sea nitrate kit, tested and the results were so high I had to go with dilution method. Long story short I've got over 64 PPM tested again to confirm as the results really surprised me. Dug out an old expired API kit and that read something closer to 10 ppm. So have 2 questions, how is it possible for the 2 kits to be that far off? Do reagents really expire and become inaccurate?
and more importantly, what do I do to get Nitrates under control.
I had low Alk levels and have slowly been raising them but stupidly assumed my nitrates were fine (till tonight).
alk, ca, and mg all slightly low but within 10% of optimal.
API kits shows 0 ammonia and nitrite
PH with hanna meter was .08 yesterday before I changed out GFO and carbon.
last water change was about 3 weeks ago.
thank in advance
 

nycfishy

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Queens NY
I some ceramic bioshperes in the backchamber, could those be contributing to high nitrates? I had added them months back with the intent they would help control it better.


Also with the API kit results, would an older expired kit give much lower results or are they just very inaccurate compared to red sea kit?
 

piranhapat

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Westchester, N.Y
First thing what are you using for your bio load. LR ect. Ceramic biospheres will help your nitrates. How old has your system be running. Nitrates are coming from over feeding. Bad skimmer and not doing weekly or monthly WC. Over stock tank. You don't have to worry about having low nitrates unless you have SPS coral. Fish only just do some WC and cut back your feeding. You can add some bacteria help biospheres break down nitrates. Need more information.
 

nycfishy

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Queens NY
I've got about 20-30 pounds of pukani live rock in the tank. Systems has been running about 24 months. Possible I am overfeeding. Skimmer is OK, largest I can fit in the back chamber. I want to keep SPS and have not been able to very interested in getting nitrates down.
Would do carbon dosing but some concern about skimmer being able ot keep up.
 

BKLYNREEF123

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Brooklyn
API kits are just not very good, even brand new. It's tempting to believe the lower reading, but I would put my money on the Red Sea kit. I would look into a bigger HOB that can keep up with your bio load. Speaking of which if worst comes to worst you may have to lower the bio load.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

nycfishy

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
Queens NY
fish wise a have pair of clowns, a diamond goby, dotyback, blood shrimp, 3 small chromis and a yellow wrasse. Some assorted snails, crabs, a serpent star and a banded star.
 

seldin

Advanced Reefer
Manhattan Reefs
Location
New York
For high nitrates I does with carbon. Takes a while to work, but corals perk up. You can read about it, if you want to go that route. However, make sure not to dose on the high side. Reef central has Randy who is an expert on chemistry if you want to start there.

Also, recommend frequent water changes and good skimmer as was suggested previously.
 
Invest the money get a better test kit, next do your weekly water change 10-15% , next if you don’t already add chaeto and a skimmer.
 

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:



Top