+1 to Aquatic Obsession. Really great livestock there. One of the few places that I've never lost a fish from. They may be a little bit more expensive but the quality is worth it IMO
whippany is tough spot, abso on 46 has alot of stuff, not crazy about them
reef encounter is ok, small selection id prob take the ride to ocean gallery
been to aqob once, didnt buy anything but they had nice looking fish available
I would suggest a slightly different route. Frags-unlimited for corals [check vendor forums]. Members for misc. Internet for dry equipment. Depends on what your looking for.
There are a few of us that can get what you need or can point you in the best directions as far as prices are concerned.
Jump on 80 and see if knockout, Kelvin, he has awesome corals as well. I believe he still works in Secaucus and drives through 80 so if you purchase from him he may be able to meet you on 80. Awesome guy but can't say I have met bad people on here!