H2O got some nice live rocks. cured, not too big. good shape. perfect for your tank. i just bought 80 lbs from them for my new tank. They are in Queens. Maybe too far from you.
i've got what use to be LR that i turned into baserock and now its LR again. It's been in my sump for months- good sizes (golf ball to baseball) no coraline or anything on it, so if its nice rock ur looking for, nevermind ;P
Mike, every now and again you may be able to find some decent "shapes" at Animal Kingdom.....but I hear you, even with my larer tanks, I'm pretty picky about LR as well.
Maybe Chris and Bill at reef Fantasy can place an order for you if you're looking for some particular LR.