As I said, it is mostly the coolness thing that matters and not if the thing actually does anything as I think it is a silly invention. I doubt the bacteria care or even know about it or what they are supposed to do. They probably look at those pellets all spinning around and get dizzy. I bet some of them even puke and we don't want bacteria puke in our reefs as it causes cyanobacteria, diatoms or even black ich. I may even install blue LEDs in mine to increase the coolness factor by at least a factor of five.
My tank runs fine with the nitrates at 40, if I lowered them much it would probably crash. As I am sure you know, I don't buy into the high nitrates/phosphates, global warming, 30 oz. soda's, or hamburger helper affects our reefs negatively as many nice looking tanks have high levels of "most" of those things. I would like my nitrates to run about 20 but I am still experimenting with these higher levels. So far I see no problems. Besides the coolness factor, I built this thing just for fun and to see if it really does anything or is just, as I presume, a silly, but really cool looking, high priced, hunk of acrylic.
In my case I feel my undergravel filter is the secret as it has functioned for so long and I never needed these funky devices.
But if I don't have one,I can't get into these complicated, and heated discussions of the pro's and con's of it.
If I could afford it I would put a manta ray in my tank (a small one) to see if they are reef safe and more important to see if it's tail would scratch my ceiling.
I have it running now in fresh water just to test for leaks and also to check if I lose any pellets out the top. I lost some but It seems when the pellets are new, they have air in them and tend to float, that abates in a few minutes and may not even be a problem in salt water. Maybe this week I will install it permanently in my tank for a test. I have the regular pellets that you are supposed to use for now. My LFS owed me a Janss pipefish and could not get it, then he owed me a cool gobi, (I forgot the name) and he could not get that, then he was supposed to get me another dragon pipefish and that fell through, so I said give me some pellets. That he could get. So being I had these silly pellets and they don't taste to good, I built a reactor to put them in. Now I will have to get a nitrate test kit
(and it breaks my heart) to test it. As you mentioned, it may be bad for my tank, but as you know, my tank is and has always been an experiment and if it crashes, it has a good run. I need to learn all about these things. I want to know everything, but some of us are getting older, and that knowledge has a way of leaving us as we age. No one here of course. :shhh: