RichMacys":29jh587s said:
What is the difference between cell and extruded?
Do you want the scientific mumbo jumbo or plain n' simple answer?
Here goes: Most commercially available acrylic is made one of two ways, extruded and cell cast. Extruded material is made like playdough, mix up a bunch of resin and squeeze it out between two steel drums on a conveyor belt, rapidly cool it, and you now have extruded material. Cell cast is made by pouring resin between two sheets of glass and letting it cure. The amount of residual stress in the extruded material is quite high, it's just inherent in the process. What this means is that in can craze easily - possibly leading to material failure. If you ever seen those little microfractures in acrylic - you know what I'm speaking of. Residual stress in the cell cast is relatively low because it was allowed to cure very slowly so it's just more stable and therefore it's propensity to craze is much lower.
Since tanks are in fact pressure vessels, it only makes sense to use the most stable material possible. Does this mean extruded won't work? nope, many do use extruded material for sumps, etc.. its just not the "preferred" material for long term structural durability.
This is the plan. I figured I could get away with 1/4" for it. But 3/8" would be less flexy. I may make it more like a 3x4 cubish thing but only 10" deep. Im going to use a couple of rubbermaid tubs for the sump unless I can find a better way.
I'd recommend 1/4" at the absolute minimum, but 3/8" would be good, as always - thicker is better.
This is going to be the first acrylic tank Ive built so I want to make sure I dont jack things up and end up with 60-70 gallons of water on the floor. What would you suggest for bracing? I will probably use a full piece for the top and hole drill the opening on four corners. Then I can use my dremel with the router attachment and a straight edge for the long cuts.
Sounds reasonable. As for bracing, this is dependent on the thickness of acrylic used. Say you use 1/4", you should use the full top and a centerbrace. This would leave you two openings measuring 18"(or so) square. If you use 1/2", you can just put one big opening measuring 20 x 44"(again, or so). Big openings are always nice cuz you have many more lighting options without wqorrying about the effect on the acrylic. If you decide on 3/8", I'd recommend a 2" flange all the way around and maybe a 4" centerbrace.
HTH,
James