I thought I'd add my experiences with
Chaetodon spp. as I have success with quite a few on the "poor" list. I should add that most of these are caught locally in Sydney during Summer and Autumn (and even early Winter). The larvae are carried down the east Australian coast by the East Australia Current and deposited at various places - some of these places tend to be hot spots. The smaller the fish are when they are caught, the better they tend to do in captivity.
For a list of the species we can catch, please see:
Collecting - Species on my site. (mmm, I need to update it as it is missing a few species.)
Of course, catching your own fish and getting them to an aquarium within a few hours will be completely different from those collected on the our side of the world and imported into the US. Nevertheless, the information should be interesting.
<blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">quote
Chaetdodon flavirostris Usually shy and non-feeding. Eats coral polyps, other bottom-dwelling invertebrates and algae in the wild. . Way too often sold to the hobby as juveniles... they don't live. This one isn't on Tullock's list either.
These are probably the most common seen
Chaetodon around Sydney and prove to be very hardy. They start to feed almost immediately and I have kept specimens for over 12 months.
<blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">quote
Chaetodon pelewensis Not on Tullock's list. No reason given for poor survival
While I have personally not caught any of this species myself (but have helped friends catch them), those that I have kept did very well and survived in the tank for multiple years.
<blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">quote
Chaetodon plebius No reason given for poor survival
These are supposedly obligate coral feeders. I recently a juvenile (not in Sydney but further north) and it was just starting to feed on
Artemia nauplii when it (and the rest of the inhabitants of the tank) succumbed to
Amyloodinium. A friend also caught one at the same time and his is still going strong two months later.
<blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">quote
Chaetodon vagabundus In the wild feeds on anemones, coral polyps, worms and algae. Not on Tullock's list.
Another common species around Sydney that does well in tanks.
One of the biggest problems I have found with
Chaetodon spp. is they do not mix well together at all. I once tried a
C. auriga,
C. citrinellis,
C. flavirostris and
C. vagabundus in the same tank (48x14x18). The
C. auriga was the most dominant and constantly harassed the other 3. The
C. citrinellus lasted nearly 2 months because of the stress and not being allowed to feed. I had to move the
C. vagabundus out after 1.3 months. The
C. flavirostris stayed in the tank for 8 months, but was regularly having minor "Ich" infections due to the stress and so I moved it to another tank.
[ January 04, 2002: Message edited by: ATJ ]</p>