I've only ordered from saltwaterfish.com once and it wasn't good at all.
I ordered a carpet anemone, two tank-raised Gold Stripe Maroon clowns and 3 queen conchs.
The carpet anemone was shipped without water in a sealed plastic bag (they told me that's the best way to ship anemones),,, let's just say it was stressed,,, and I couldn't get it to recover,, died after about a week.
The tank raised Gold Stripe Maroons were the poorest-looking inbred abominations I've ever come across,,, poor color,, two stripes and the worst underbite,, which never went away.
After trying (and failing) to pair each of these in turn with my adult female GSM Clown, I gave them away to a friend,,, a year or so later and the problem was revealed,, they were white strip maroons all along (they're now merrily producing even uglier offspring in my friends tank).
Oh,, and one of the conchs was DOA.