• Why not take a moment to introduce yourself to our members?

Status
Not open for further replies.

skylab1

Experienced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
FragMaster":25l2h6mp said:
so any ways.............
how about some pics of your set up skylab? Your shop, your tanks ect ect...
Get your camera back yet?

Canon has my camera, I just glad I purchase extended warranty on the thing.
 

FragMaster

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So we are agreed the "oxygen" exchange happens on the surface. Now, tell me which of the following does oxygen exchange happend more or faster on the surface.
Calm, flat water or water that move up and down on the surface?
Turbulent water. What is this man 6th grade science? Get to the real issues please.
Like the pics I aksed you for of your "business".

That's called transship.
So are you saying wholesaler in the U.S. that either have their own collecting staton or contracted collecting station over seas don't have to pay shipping to ship back to the states? Wow, the airline ship for free for them Really?
Andy , Andy, Andy.....
wholsalers in the U.S: Florida whosalers tend to focus on caribbean coral and fish only. "wholesalers" in the US that do not collect thier own stock are what we call "retail/wholesalers" Ie most of the big shops on the west coast.
These individuals dont contract out to any one. They simply place orders as needed. They sell "Retail" to individuals via walk in shopping, or online, and also offer wholesale pricing for vendors (other retailers).
when they wholesale it is for a bit more than they paid for it from thier wholesaler ( ofcourse) but it is not transhipped. I dont know of any one in the industry that will tranship a customer live fish or live coral with out ever seeing it. They only do that with live rock normaly guy.
SO guess what? The "retail/wholsalers" are realy just "retailers" in the long run of it. They pay true wholesale, and pay for shipping = retailer.


Gerber's Saltwater Warehouse fort exapmle here in Ohio is one of them. They offer both. Email them and ask.
http://www.saltwaterwarehouse.com/productsandservices/


BTW, the currect going rate for airline cargo charged by the wholesaler oversea is about $5.45-$5.75US/kg not counting packaging and box charge, clearance, cites if required, ice/heat pack charge.

Average shipping cost for air frieght is $1.00-$1.80 per lb from most retailers online to the consumer. $60 and up per 100lbs from a wholesaler. It all depends on how much wieght your wholesaler overseas ships with the air frieght co. he/she uses as to what sort of discount they can pass on to you. Box charges ( usualy the same from retailers to customers as well) usualy average $6-$12 per box depending on size of the box, and heat/cold packs needed. ALSO it depends on if your order is COD or not becase that carries an extra charge with the airline as well depending on the total cost of shipping with them. They have a minimum wieght and minimum sales number that must be fufilled by the retailer as well in most all cases.

Man I have no idea where you get your numbers, your buying strategy, or your information as a whole about this business, but if it is from a consultant FIRE HIM, if its from a friend SMACK'EM.

"I dont have a shop I do this part time on the weekends"

Then why act like your a big player and have been in the business for years wholesaling?

Also post some pics of "your" 75g tank you said you have running on the same "system". Pics of equipment, and the live stock.
detailed shots please.
 

reefnanny

New Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Was this about a 5 gallon nano tank or a spelling quiz? I can't figure it out. Who cares about spelling when we can talk about reef tanks? :roll:
 

GSchiemer

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
FWIW & IMO, spelling counts for something and I wouldn't summarily dismiss it. It denotes intelligence and a thoughtful reply. It also lends additional credence to a post.

Greg
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
It's amazing how some things seem to come up again every so often. Against my better judgement I'm going to add to this thread.

Back in 1998 two things happened in quick succession. I had a run in with Snake at his booth at MACNA that year, and shortly afterwards Snake started posting to the [email protected] mailing list I ran along with Jimmy Chen.

The result of those postings was very similiar to what's gone on in this thread. With one exception. Snake offered to provide a sample of his product if someone would give it a try and report on the validity (or lack thereof) of his claims.

I volunteered. I ran a 6 gallon eclipse I had sitting around for a month I think it was using Snake's product. If memory serves I tested it with five green chromis.

Ammonia, nitrate and nitrite were not detectable throughout that time period, using Salifert kits (what I had at my disposal at the time, having a large number of them on hand from having done product testing on them shortly before for the now long-defunct Reef Reviews).

Can I tell you how the product works? Nope. Can I tell you if it's suitable for long term use? Nope. Do I think it has any legitimate use for a reef tank for any purpose other then possibly during the very first days of curing live rock? Nope. But does it do what it claims to? As far as I could tell... yeah.

FWIW.
 

FragMaster

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hey thats what were looking for!
Thank you!
An outside unbiased opinion from someone who has used it was in great need here.
So how did you set it up? Did you still perform water changes?
Did it replace any mechanical filtration you were using?
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So how did you set it up? Did you still perform water changes?
Did it replace any mechanical filtration you were using?

Do bear in mind this was the better part of 10 years ago and I have a hard enough time remembering last week 8)

Tank was set up specifically to try out the stuff. No water changes were performed (and I don't believe it was even topped off, very little evaporation on those eclipse 6 units). Water was NSW (Catalina brand, readily available in socal). There was no mechanical filtration, skimming, live rock, live sand or anything else. An empty 6 gallon tank, a small canister filter running the media (I seem to recall the instructions at the time saying something about it being neccessary to run the media under pressure, hence the canister), NSW, a heater and a handful of green chromis. It really was that basic.

If someone knows where the [email protected] archive is these days, it may be possible to find the relevent posts from that period.
 

FragMaster

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
WHat were your parameters at the end of the trial?
Most importantly why did you not switch everything over to it if it were
that easy and worked so well?
No water top offs for a month seems a little extreme in a 6g though guy?
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
WHat were your parameters at the end of the trial?

From memory, ammonia, nitrate and nitrite were all reading as undetectable. I remember checking a few other things for the hell of it, but nothing that stands out in my mind as out of the ordinary, results wise.

Most importantly why did you not switch everything over to it if it were
that easy and worked so well?

What would have been the point? I had a well established tank with zero ammonia and nitrites, and very very low nitrates anyway, in a system that I -knew- how it worked (live rock, skimmer, DSB).

Besides, it should be obvious that if you short circuit the ammonia->nitrite-nitrate cycle, then the bacteria in any life rock/sand in the tank would by neccessity scale back due to having their source of inputs limited. I'd be concerned about that for two reasons. First, it would dramatically lessen the carrying capacity of the rock in the event of a short-term crisis. Second, god knows what effect that might have had on other life in the tank - I didn't, and why find out the hard way?

No water top offs for a month seems a little extreme in a 6g though guy?

Nah. Form fitting, full enclosing hood. Doubt the tank lost even 1/4 cup of water to evaporation over the whole month.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
cjdevito":23behhyl said:
So how did you set it up? Did you still perform water changes?
Did it replace any mechanical filtration you were using?

Do bear in mind this was the better part of 10 years ago and I have a hard enough time remembering last week 8)

Sooooooo...........it's not New Science just brought back to life science.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Sooooooo...........it's not New Science just brought back to life science.

Oh yeah, definitely. MACNA X, 1998 - Snake was there then, selling this stuff. Hadn't heard it mentioned in years, until now.
 

FragMaster

Advanced Reefer
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
But yet no reports of alkalinity drops, no calcium precipitation, and no
Ph problems.
An aboslute miracle of "new science". :)


His posting on "the other board" are just insanity.

Give him more rope. This should turn out to be the most attended public hanging in history.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
FragMaster":uz8dhf05 said:
But yet no reports of alkalinity drops, no calcium precipitation, and no
Ph problems.
An aboslute miracle of "new science". :)

I think I just wasted a lot of time on someone misrepresenting themselves. Dang, I hate it when that happens.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Sponsor Reefs

We're a FREE website, and we exist because of hobbyists like YOU who help us run this community.

Click here to sponsor $10:


Top