I respect your opinion Dace.. and like your signature says "I give advice strictly onwhat has worked for me, even if there’s some of you that my state it did not work for you." :0)
I would say it all depends on the situation.. I wouldn't use Aptaisia X in a 340 gallons.. oh no that is just impossible... in my case, I have a 50 breeder and my liverock structure allows me to reach everyspot in the LR.. and I saw one of my shrimp eating one aptaisia after I treated it.. it was like food for them..
I was gonna buy the nudis .. thats why I opened this tread but I was not able to find them and I heard they are expensive ...Aptaisia X is like 10 bucks and shrimp are 10~15 bucks not that I am cheap .but aptaisia was driving me nuts.. I was using Kalk and that didnt work for me..
so in my case and perhaps it is ONLY my case Aptaisia X and peppermit shrimp are working.. :0) for now.. you never know.. I will update this tread in couple of months..
Domboski - I would go for that.. the only concern in my case is the number of fish I can put in my tank..