Thanks to shared knowledge, advancements in husbandry paired with state-of the art equipment and better understanding of corals biology, more people are able to create and maintain beautiful reef tanks. Despite all we know about keeping marine life in captivity, there is no one recipe for all problems and challenges associated with reef aquariums. Magic potions, miracles-in a bottle, innovative equipment and countless dosing variations are all part of a quest to find the Holy Grail, but so far, it just doesn’t exist. Every single reef aquarium is different, starting from source of water, salt mix used, lighting up to the choice of animals housed. Count into that the sophisticated nature of sessile invertebrates, their chemical interactions and enormous range of habitats they are collected from and we quickly realize there is no “sweet point” and the best we could do is create optimal conditions for corals to live and propagate.
All images by author
There are, however, two aspects every successful reef story share: water changes and knowing your saltwater parameters. While the first is obvious – no nutrient reducing chemical can substitute for good ol’ water change, testing for parameters requires some basic knowledge about seawater elements and their importance in reef dwelling fish and invertebrates husbandry.
Basic parameters every reefer needs to know and check regularly are temperature, salinity, ammonia levels and pH of water. In order to provide for most photosynthetic corals and other invertebrates, we need to control nutrients in water by testing for phosphates (PO4) and nitrates (NO3). Finally, all stony corals use calcium carbonate to build their skeleton, therefore in order to supplement their grow we need to regularly test for calcium (Ca), alkalinity (kH) and Magnesium (Mg) dissolved in water. Finding the right balance between those three coral building elements is a key to maintain a successful stony corals and clams dominated reef tank.
To check for all those elements, we use aquarium grade test kits that are readily available on the market. When shopping for test kits, consumer’s choice is driven by several factors:
-accuracy- this one is obvious, if test is not accurate it doesn’t serve it’s purpose and should be disregarded
-easiness of use- we hobbyists are patient people, but nobody is willing to spend too much time figuring out how to prepare water sample and read test results
-price to value ratio- how many tests one can perform before running out of reagents
– clearly stated expiration date
Red Sea Reef Foundation Pro Test kit is a topic of today’s review and a part of Red Sea new line called Red Sea Coral Care, featuring several products from salt mix, major and trace elements supplements, coral growth and color enhancers to various test kits. Let’s find out how Red Sea‘s multikit stands against other major brands in terms of accuracy, user-friendliness and value.
Red Sea Reef Foundation Pro Test kit consist off separate test kits for three major elements directly responsible for stony corals growth and well-being- Calcium, Alkalinity and Magnesium, sold as one package. Let’s peer inside the box and see what’s hidden there…
The outer cardboard packaging informs us about the product inside in several different languages. The accuracy, range and approximate number of tests are printed as a table on the back. On the bottom we have a clearly printed expiration date (mine is 04/15). First positive surprise comes right after unpacking the box, in a form of a sturdy-looking, black plastic container that holds all testing equipment.
No more flimsy cardboard boxes that fell apart with prolonged use. Very nice, indeed! Pop the lid and little chemistry lab reveals itself, tightly packed inside the box. Reef Foundation Pro Test Kit includes:
-one 10ml syringe for water samples
-three, color coded (one for each test kit) 1ml syringes
a plastic device called Titrator (more on that later)
-60ml plastic bottle filled with alkalinity reagent
-three bottles of Ca reagents plus a measuring spoon
-three bottles of Mg reagents
-printed instruction for Reef Care Program
-three splash-proof cards (one for each test) with instructions and test kit results table
-three glass vials clipped to the top part of the package
The package leaves very good first impression, with only one plastic container Red Sea managed to fit all three test kits with additional testing equipment, saving precious space in the “fish closet”. Color coded reagent plastic caps and syringe nozzles prevents unwanted mixing of different solutions. However, the most interesting part of Red Sea Test Kit is the earlier mentioned Titrator.
This clever little device is a test vial and 1ml testing syringe holder. The bottom part is where you screw in the vial, while the rubber gasket holds the syringe firmly, preventing any “missed” drops.
Using titrator is a breeze- adding reagent drops and mixing solution becomes a one hand operation while the seal between testing vial and titrator eliminates possible spills.
Each of the three test kits comes with a card laminated in plastic foil. On one side we have a test kit symbol and numbered steps of testing procedure, accompanied with simple, easy to understand illustrations. Reverse side of each card features test results divided into the amount of titrant (testing solution in the 1ml syringe) used and associated test result (alkalinity in Meg/l as well as dkH and both Mg and Ca in ppm). Let’s take a closer look at how each test kit performs:
a) Alkalinity test
Alkalinity test is fastest of the three tests to execute and shouldn’t take more than 2 minutes. You simply add 10ml water sample into the vial, then fill 1ml syringe with kH reagent, followed by mounting the vial and syringe onto Titrator.
Adding first couple of drops into the test vial turns test water blue. Then add the reagent drop-by drop until the water turns dark pink, read the end position of syringe’s plunger and subtract the result from initial value of 1ml. Compare your result with table to know your Alkalinity level.
Calcium test begins with adding 5ml of test water to the vial, followed by 5 drops of Ca reagent A and shaking the solution for 10 seconds.
Next step is to add a level spoonful powder reagent B to the vial and mix the solution for another 20 seconds, until it turns uniform pink.
Mount vial and syringe filled with Ca reagent C onto Titrator and add reagent drop by drop while gently swirling, until the solution turns dark blue. As with kH test, the difference between start and end position of the syringe’s plunger tells the amount of reagent C used and therefore the Calcium level in ppm units
Magnesium test takes a little more time than the other two and it’s very similar in executing to those of other major test kit brands. First you add 2ml of test water to glass vial, followed by 5 drops of Mg reagent A and 15 seconds of shaking/swirling in between each drop added.
Next add 5 drops of Mg reagent B and shake for additional 60 seconds.
The solution turns pink and it’s mounted on Titrator with a syringe filled with Mg reagent C.
Add this reagent to the vial drop by drop until it turns from pink to dark blue, which marks the end of testing and the result can be compared to the table on Mg test instruction card.
It’s worth mentioning all bottles that require adding drops of reagent liquid into solution have firm nozzles dispensing equal drops every time the bottles are squeezed. I hate when my testing procedure is compromised by accidental drops of reagent. The 1ml syringe is clearly marked using 0.01ml increments and the color change in all three tests is evident and clear to spot.
Red Sea promises following accuracy for its test kits:
- +/- 5ppm for Calcium
- +/- 20ppm for Magnesium
- +/- 0.05 meq/l (less than 0.1 dKH)
I didn’t have the opportunity to laboratory test my water samples, but I’ve compared Red Sea test kits with other two major test kit manufacturers- Elos and Salifert and found them identical . Additionally, I’ve performed KH test using laboratory checked 6.7dKH solution and it proved to be dead accurate. I have no doubt Red Sea tests accuracy is in par with leading aquarium grade test kits manufacturers on the market.
Red Sea Reef Foundation Pro Test Kit costs around $50-$60 at online stores, which is a great value compared to buying each test kit separately (Calcium and Magnesium test cost $30-$35 each and KH test is priced around $25). In addition to that, Red Sea offers Reagent Refill kits for around $13, so basically after spending $50-$60 initially, the cost of new MG,Ca and kH test kits drop down to $13 each time you buy new kit. Both Calcium and Alkalinity test last for approximately 75 test, while Magnesium allows for 60 separate tests, which, compared to other major brands, is industry’s average.
-great, quality packaging and the addition of plastic case is a big plus
-color coding prevents accidentally mixing solutions
-Titrator is a versatile, easy to use device
-easy to read instruction and not overly complicated testing procedure
-color shift in all three test kits is evident and very easy to spot
-very good price-to-value ratio, especially when counting in Reagent Refill Kits
-accuracy comparable to other major test kit brands
None I can think of
I have to admit I was trying hard to find something I wouldn’t like in Red Sea Reef Foundation Pro Test Kit and I failed. It offers very good accuracy, great packaging, market leading price-to value ratio and each test follows a simple, fairly time-saving procedure that is easy to remember and repeat. Being a SPS keeper that need to check his levels on a regular basis, Red Sea made me switch to using their kits as a preferred method of testing my water. If you’re looking for an accurate, user-friendly test kit that won’t leave your pockets empty, I recommend trying Red Sea Reef Foundation Pro Test Kit. Happy reefing!